| Lewis Hawke | 10 | The New Saints, St Mirren Colts, Stirling Albion, Albion Rovers, Nomads, Stirling Albion, Albion Rovers, Berwick Rangers, Elgin City, Berwick Rangers |
| Scott Mclean | 9 | St Mirren Colts, St Mirren Colts (pen), Stirling Albion (pen), Berwick Rangers x 2 (1 pen), Cowdenbeath (pen), Albion Rovers x 2 (2 pen), Berwick Rangers (pen) |
| David Galt | 6 | Berwick Rangers x 2, Annan Athletic, Elgin City x3 |
| Kurtis Roberts | 5 | Spartans, Albion Rovers, Berwick Rangers x 2, Elgin City |
| Ciaran Summers | 4 | Peterhead x 2, Albion Rovers, Berwick Rangers |
| Smart Osadolor | 3 | Annan Athletic, The New Saints, Albion Rovers |
| Scott Gibson | 3 | Spartans, Peterhead, Peterhead |
| Kieran Moore | 3 | Elgin City, Berwick Rangers, Berwick Rangers |
| Josh Peters | 2 | Elgin City, Clyde (pen) |
| Jamie McKernon | 2 | Berwick Rangers(pen), Albion Rovers |
| Euan East | 2 | St Mirren Colts, Clyde |
| Billy Mortimer | 1 | Albion Rovers |
| Gerry McLauchlan | 1 | Stirling Albion |
| Dom McLaren | 1 | Albion Rovers |
| Michael Ruth | 1 | Albion Rovers |
