| Zak Rudden | 15 | Peterhead, Livingston, Airdrieonians, Dunfermline Athletic, Annan Athletic, Greenock Morton, Hamilton Academical (pen), Montrose, Greenock Morton, East Kilbride (x2), Raith Rovers, Ayr United, Aberdeen, Greenock Morton |
| Jack Turner | 13 | Peterhead, Hibernian, Kelty Hearts (x2), Airdrieonians, Edinburgh City, Hamilton Academical, Dunfermline Athletic, Ayr United, Rangers B, Livingston (x2), Ayr United |
| Dom Thomas | 7 | Elgin City, Kelty Hearts, Falkirk, Greenock Morton, Rangers B, Airdrieonians, Partick Thistle |
| Roddy MacGregor | 7 | Peterhead, Elgin City (x2), Kelty Hearts (x2), Partick Thistle, Ayr United |
| Liam McLeish | 4 | Peterhead, Annan Athletic, Raith Rovers, Montrose |
| Ryan Duncan | 4 | Annan Athletic, Dunfermline Athletic, Raith Rovers, East Kilbride |
| Seb Drozd | 4 | Livingston, Rangers, Ayr United, Raith Rovers |
| Josh Scott | 3 | Elgin City, Montrose, Airdrieonians |
| Sean Welsh | 3 | Kelty Hearts, Dunfermline Athletic, Hamilton Academical |
| Louis Longridge | 2 | Partick Thistle, Airdrieonians |
| Reece Evans | 2 | East Kilbride (x2) |
| Nikola Ujdur | 2 | Annan Athletic, Raith Rovers |
| Zach Mauchin | 1 | Peterhead |
| Cammy Kerr | 1 | Ayr United |
| Josh Hinds | 1 | Ayr United |
| Adam Devine | 1 | Raith Rovers |
| Adam Montgomery | 1 | Raith Rovers |
